TheDojo
Gears of War: E-Day cover

The Honor Dojo Judgment

Gears of War: E-Day

By Redlotus · October 7, 2026

← Back to Game
5.5

Unproven

Our Judgment

A prequel that remembers how to shoot but forgets who it was supposed to be about.

A chainsaw does not ask permission, but a good soldier does not ask for a speech.
This old Sensei has sat through enough speeches.

I came to E-Day the way I come to every Gears game: with a full tank, a clean cover button, and a hunger to watch two big men tear the world apart. This one goes back to the beginning. It's set fourteen years before the first game, shortly after the Pendulum Wars, with younger Marcus Fenix and Dom Santiago on the front lines as the Locust come up out of the ground. That's the pitch. Brotherhood, brutality, a world coming apart. If you'd shown me that as a trailer in 2006, I'd have tattooed it on my forearm.

And for stretches, it delivers. Shooting Locust still feels incredible, and the weapons carry the weight you expect. The movement is more agile than before: you can slide, jump, mantle over cover, and climb ledges. The first Emergence Day sections are the best the series has ever looked and felt. Watching a functioning city fall apart until you're the last squad left in it is exactly the atmosphere this game needed. Credit where it's earned.

Then the problems start showing.

Gears of War: E-Day artwork
Gears of War: E-Day artwork

The open-world filler. I will say this once and slowly: Gears is not an open-world game. Even the friendly critics admit the open sections have dull side objectives and collectibles that wreck the pacing. The linear missions are far better, and those are the ones that feel like Gears. Every minute you spend wandering a field looking for a lunchbox is a minute stolen from a chainsaw.

What got cut. Players are listing the casualties, and the list is long: no chainsaw duels, no grenade tagging, no meat shield, very few executions, no private lobbies, and Horde has been called bland compared to what came before. These aren't deep-cut features. They're Gears. You cut the chainsaw duel from a Gears game, you've cut the heart out of the man.

The writing. One critic called the story fairly boilerplate and written for newcomers rather than veterans. I'd go further. The game seems more interested in telling you what to feel than in earning it. It reaches for themes like people in power abdicating responsibility, and the union background of a troubled central character, and it never lets Marcus and Dom just be Marcus and Dom. Brotherhood is supposed to be the spine of this series. In E-Day it keeps getting pushed aside for threads that want to be profound.

Gears of War: E-Day gameplay screenshot 2
Gears of War: E-Day gameplay screenshot 2

Now, the question I know half of you are here for. Yes, I know the discourse is loud. A Steam reviewer noted there's been plenty of talk about E-Day being "woke," and the internet has already picked its trenches. Here's where this old Sensei lands, and he won't pretend otherwise.

E-Day gives you playable Kalona locals in Lucas Reyes and Mags Carter, people who ground you in what the city was like before it became a mass grave. I don't mind the idea. I mind where the camera points. Gears at its best is two soldiers and the weight between them. Every time the game cuts away to someone else's story, I feel the focus drift, and the drift hurts the game more than any one character ever could. That's a pacing complaint. It would be the same complaint if the extra spotlight went to a man.

And let's keep the series honest. There have been women in the COG since the first game: Anya on the radio, Sam in the line. I never complained then, because they were written as soldiers, not as banners. Judge the character, not the headline. When the writing is sharp, I don't care who delivers the line. When it's preachy, I notice no matter who it is. E-Day has both kinds of scene, and I would rather it had more of the first.

Gears of War: E-Day gameplay screenshot 7
Gears of War: E-Day gameplay screenshot 7

The numbers? Critics are kinder than I am. The Metascore sits at 87, and reviewers praise the spectacle, the action set pieces, and the return to the series' roots. I read the other side, too: GameSpot gave it a 7 and called the campaign buried in the past, "mostly more of the same." That sounds about right to me. A strong coat of paint over a familiar frame.

Is it too easy? Yes, on the default settings. Gears used to bite when you got sloppy in cover. Here the game is more interested in showing you the spectacle than punishing you for missing it. Crank the difficulty and it improves, but the game shouldn't make me do that.

The Coalition clearly loves this series. The visuals are among the best I've seen on an Xbox, the Locust are properly scary again, and the campaign has hours that melt away. But a prequel has one job: make me feel what I felt in 2006. E-Day gets close, then wanders off to chase a collectible.